 Photograph by F.A. Rinehart, 1889 |
Part I
The Dartmoor area of England, where I make
my home, is a landscape rich with ancient magic: standing stones, castles,
bronze age ruins, and all the legends that go along with them. It is an
easy task to write about mythology in a place where old tales linger in
the land, where the fires of winter solstice are still lit in the old
stone circles on the moor -- a ritual that is as old as time, marking
the passing of the Seasonal King, invoking the sun's return.
But as the nights grow long and the days
grow cold, each winter I pack up my old stone cottage, entrust my cat
to the care of friends, and return to a little house in the desert in
my own native land. An English friend asked me if it is difficult to write
about mythology during the portion of the year when I live in the United
States, "in a land so new, and with no myths of its own." The
opinion that ours is a land without a folklore tradition is not an uncommon
one in Europe, or even among some Americans. This impression might be
supported by a quick perusal of the books popular in the fantasy field,
written by American authors yet set in Celtic or pseudo-Celtic lands.
But a more careful study of current mythic literature reveals that there
is also a body of works drawing upon distinctly American folk traditions:
the myths, tales and lore of "Turtle Island" -- as various tribal
peoples have called our continent.
As I ponder my English friend's question,
and its assumptions about American culture, I am sitting in the desert
house where I've spent winters for the last decade: a quiet spot on the
outskirts of Tucson, just north of the Mexico border. Coyotes howl in
the surrounding hills -- the star of local Trickster legends in which
Coyote plays the Hero or the Fool, both wise and dangerous all at once.
The saguaro cactus outside the window remind me of the Indian belief that
these enormous cactus contain the peaceable souls of the dead. If you
live a good and righteous life, you come back to earth as one of these
cactus, growing tall over hundreds of years; if you are not among the
righteous, you must come back again as a human being. Just north of here
are Anasazi ruins as ancient as any to be found in England. To the west,
the Hohokam's petroglyphs are etched onto the mountain rocks, images as
mysterious as that vanished tribe themselves. In the Yaqui pueblos close
to town, the Deer Dancers prepare for the spring ceremonies, extraordinary
rituals mixing Indian, Spanish and Christian myth. South of town is "The
White Dove of the Desert", the mission church of San Xavier del Bac,
built in the 1780s. Inside the mission, the statues of the saints are
decorated with photographs, gifts and tin milagros left by people
seeking miracles. Downtown just yesterday, at one of the local intertribal
powwows, the old Native American songs, the drums, the costumes, the prayers
reflected a mix of cultural traditions -- a mythology that is neither
dead nor locked away in dusty academic books, but still a vital part of
daily life for many people.
The very idea of "the American West"
has a whole folklore tradition of its own: cowboys and Indians, banditos,
pioneers and the stories that surrounded them. In the West, Anglo, Hispanic
and Native American folkways have collided and merged. In Arizona, with
its shrines and sacred mountains, its tall tales and tribal creation myths,
the oral folk tradition is still very much alive. This land, like England,
is steeped in legends -- and so, no, it's not hard to write about mythology
here. Yet the myths of this landscape, this desert, are only one small
part of the lore of Turtle Island.
Ours is a huge country, compared to those
of Europe. Its most salient characteristic (both its greatest strength
and weakness) is the sheer diversity that comes of a largely immigrant
population. The American folk tradition is thus equally diverse, encompassing
not only the ancient stories of the original native peoples, but the stories
that have come to this land along with three centuries of immigration.
The American Folklore Society, founded in 1888, separated this large body
of folk material into four basic parts: the relics of British folklore;
the lore of unacculturated immigrant groups (the French, the Spanish,
etc.); African American folklore; and Native American folklore. In Part
I of this column, we'll look at the first three categories, as well as
modern mythic novels that were inspired by them; in Part II, we'll look
at the various mythologies that fall under the Native American heading.
"Relics of British folklore" make
up the largest part of the American folk tradition -- by which I mean
oral storytelling, ballads, folk beliefs, folk dramas, and the like. We
are an English-speaking culture; this common language gives us all a grounding
in the British tradition, no matter what our ethnic background or color
of skin. But British lore brought to the United States has been changed
by the nature of this land and its peoples. The early Anglo settlers of
the eastern seaboard were largely a hard-working, plain-speaking and pious
group (leaving aside all of the Englishmen and women who came as criminals
banished to the Colonies). The Americanized tales and songs reflect this
plain-speaking attitude, and are stripped of all but the vestiges of the
paganism that suffuses old British lore. You will find few fairies in
the Americanized tales; often the Devil has taken their place, and the
heroes are simple, clever folk who find ways to outwit him. My Tucson
house-mate Ellen Steiber was researching local folklore for a story collection
recently, and what she noticed was that much of American folklore consists
of tall tales. She notes, "I began to wonder if our propensity for
tall tales didn't have something to do with settlers coming over from
the smaller European countries. They found themselves in this this vast,
expansive land, and perhaps the land itself shaped heroes and deeds to
match its almost incomprehensible scale . . . ."
In the eastern United States, the huge Appalachian
mountain range is one of the places where the oral folk tradition still
remains the strongest. The celebrated English folklore collector Cecil
Sharp made a famous excursion into the mountains of North Carolina in
1916-1917, and published the massive, classic volume of English Folk
Songs from the Southern Appalachians. It was not until 1925, however,
with the publication of Isabel Gordon Carter's Tales from the Southern
Blue Ridge, that folklorists realized that a whole body of magical
tales which were no longer extant in Britain had taken root in the New
World. These are the "Jack" tales, a cycle of stories about
an engaging young hero who (according to folklorist Richard Chase) "has
acquired the easy-going, unpretentious rural American manners that make
him so different from his English cousin, the cocksure, dashing young
hero of English fairy tales." Chase's collection, The
Jack Tales, is an excellent resource for anyone interested in
this lively material, as well as Buying
the Wind: Regional Folklore in the United States, the classic
text on American regional folklore by Richard M. Dorson.
Orson Scott Card has echoed the homespun
magic of these eastern mountain tales in Seventh
Son and the subsequent books of his "Alvin Maker" series.
These books tell the story of the pioneers who crossed the Appalachians
and headed west in a magical America where charms, hexes, beseechings,
potions, dowsers, and Second Sight are all part of daily life. Card has
skillfully blended the rich magic of the white, black and red cultures
of the early 1800s into a uniquely American fantasy. The late Manly Wade
Wellman was a gifted writer from the pulp magazine era, as well as a historian
whose works on southern American history once earned him a Pulitzer nomination.
Wellman blended American history and myth in his "Silver John"
stories (collected in Who
Fears the Devil) about a minstrel with a silver-stringed guitar,
wandering the Appalachian mountains having supernatural adventures. Reminicent
of Wellman's work, William F. Wu has written stories published in many
genre magazines chronicling the ghostly adventures of one Jack Hong in
the Ozark Mountains of Missouri. What makes Wu's work distinctive is his
beautiful rendering of the Asian magic brought to America by Chinese immigrants.
Also of note, Sharyn McCrumb's gripping novel The
Hangman's Beautiful Daughter, a magical, musical mystery set in
the mountains of Tennessee.
Several writers use "the relics of
British lore" in contemporary stories so deeply rooted in North American
landscapes that they can truly be called American mythic fiction. Alice
Hoffman does this with Turtle
Moon, a book of subtle magic set in the tropical heat of Florida,
and in Practical
Magic, a tale of witches in a small New England town. (Ignore
the silly movie of the same title; it bears only slight resemblance to
this wonderful book.) John Crowley does this in Little,
Big, a modern classic of mythic fiction set in rural New York
State and the streets of Manhattan. The stories in Jack Cady's The
Sons of Noah invests the Midwest and Northwest with a distinctly
American enchantment, as does Nina Kiriki Hoffman's novel The
Silent Strength of Stones. Reginal McKnight casts magic onto The
Kind of Light That Shines on Texas; other excellent Texan tales
are Lunatics
by Bradley Denton and Mockingbird
by Sean Stewart, as well as Mr.
Death and the Redheaded Woman, a delightful children's book by
Helen Eustis.
While English folklore may be the largest
immigrant influence on the American folk tradition, the stories and beliefs
of other nations have permeated our culture. In fact, the most popular
fairy tales known to generations of American children (Hansel and Gretel,
Beauty and the Beast, Cinderella, The Little Mermaid, etc.) are not English
but German, French, or by Denmark's Hans Christian Andersen. Richard Dorson
(in Buying the Wind) has collected the stories, "noodle tales"
and proverbs of the Pennsylvania Deutch (more commonly known as the Pennsylvania
Dutch), whose German language turned into a rich, strange dialect here
in America. I grew up with these tales from my mother's people: whimsical
stories of devils and hexes, wizards (called brauchers), and a prankish
simpleton (or "noodle" character) called Tyl Eulenspiegel. These
stories, like the Anglo-Appalachian tales, have a folksy, plain-speaking
American flavor very different from the European German tales (called
marchen) collected by the Brothers Grimm. Nancy Springer's
The Hex Witch of Seldom is a gorgeous and under-rated book based
on Pennsylvania Deutch folklore; Springer, who is a Pennsylvania native,
does an excellent job of using this material to create a fresh and moving
adult novel.
Mr. Dorson devotes another section of Buying
the Wind to the colorful lore of the Louisiana Cajuns, who have turned
the French language, culture, and music into something uniquely their
own. One of the best books on the subject is Louisiana Folktales,
retold in both French dialect and English by Alcee Fortier and published
by the American Folklore Society, 1895. The book is divided into animal
tales, in which the tricky Compair Lapin (rabbit) is always getting in
and out of trouble; and wonderful, magical fairy tales with an unusual
Cajun flavor. For modern works with a cajun flavor, try Dakota Lane's
romantic young adult novel Johnny
Voodoo, or Jewell Parker Rhodes's first novel, Voodoo
Dreams, based on the real-life story of "Voodoo Queen"
Marie Laveau. I also highly recommend the magical film Eve's
Bayou.
Voodoo magic was a part of the folklore
tradition found all across the South. In the 1890s, African American writer
Charles W. Chesnutt published a collection of stories called The
Conjure Woman, based on oral tales from the South in the years
before the Civil War. Originally written in a thick dialect, the stories
have been retold in a more accessible form by Ray Anthony Shepard in Conjure
Tales. "Conjuring," writes Shepard, "was the belief
that certain people, called conjure doctors, had supernatural powers.
They exercised these powers with the aid of roots, herbs and many other
kinds of ingredients. The conjure woman worked the roots by rubbing them
in her hands, or moving the root between her fingers." Unlike Chesnutt's
white contemporaries (such as Joel Chandler Harris, author of the better
known "Uncle Remus" tales) who penned hearty, folksy stories
drawing upon the southern black folk tradition, Chesnutt's tales do not
hide the painful realities of lives lived in slavery.
More recently, the skilled science fiction
writer Octavia E. Butler has written a powerful American time-travel fantasy,
Kindred,
that also draws upon the history and lore of black slaves in the south.
Toni Morrison's unforgettable novel, Beloved,
which won the 1988 Pulitzer Prize, is a haunting, heartbreaking ghost
story, using fantasy to explore rural American history just after the
Civil War. Charlotte Watson Sherman is one of the best of the modern writers
drawing upon the African American folkloric tradition to tell contemporary
magical realist stories in her entertaining collection Killing
Color. Randall Kenan, who was raised in North Carolina, has been
hailed by critics as "our 'black' Marquez." This master storyteller's
extraordinary work can be found in Let
the Dead Bury Their Dead. Bob Shacochis is another writer who
has worked with the ghostly magic of southeastern states (as well as with
Caribbean myths) in the stories that make up his collection The
Next New World.
Spanish-speaking Americans have one of the
most vivid folkloric traditions in this country. While this can be found
throughout the United States, it is most evident among the Spanish Americans
of northern New Mexico and the Mexican Americans in the border states
of Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California. A typical and ubiquitious
example is the legend of the Weeping Woman, La Llorona -- a story
that has existed since Aztec times (and may be connected to the Aztec
goddess Civacoatl). The tale has been attached to various historical personages,
but the basic motif remains the same: a highborn man makes love to a beautiful
peasant girl who bears him three children. When he abandons her to marry
a woman of his own class (or own race, in the versions where the man is
Spanish and the woman Indian), the girl kills her children, and then wanders
the hills forevermore, wailing and shrieking her loss. Her ghost now appears
as a woman in white with long black hair, fingernails of tin, and the
face of a bat, a horse, or a skeleton. She is often found in dry river
beds, and encountering her can be fatal. Once again, Dorson's Buying
the Wind provides an introduction to these legends and myths, but
for a more extensive exploration, I recommend John O. West's Mexican-American
Folklore.
Lately there has been a renaissance of fiction
by Spanish-speaking Americans. In
Other Words, edited by Roberta Fernandez, is a terrific, fat recent
collection of literature by Latinas of the United States, and includes
lovely magic realist works. Sandra Cisneros is a talented writer who mixes
realism and magical realism in story collections such as Woman
Hollering Creek; as does Ana Castillo in charming novels such
as So
Far From God. Kathleen Alcala is a writer whose work spans the
Mexican American border region in the novel Spirits
of the Ordinary and the story collection Mrs.
Vargas and the Dead Naturalist. George Szantos is a Canadian author
who lives part of each year in Mexico. His witty and magical cycle of
stories collected in The
Underside of Stones is highly recommended. Also recommended is
Laura Esquivel's Like
Water for Chocolate (a novel complete with recipes!), as well
as the luminous film of the same title that was made from it.
It is this skillful mix of cultural traditions
that is the hallmark of American mythic fiction. We find it in Karen Joy
Fowler's brilliant Sarah
Canary, set in the Washington Territory of 1873, the story of
a Chinese railway worker and a mysterious woman in black. We find it in
Midori Synder's The
Flight of Michael McBride, an enchanting novel of the American
southwest. Also set in the late 1800s, it is the story of a young Irishman
from New York City whose Old World traditions collide with the various
immigrant and native folklore traditions on the Texas frontier. "What
I found interesting in working with so many different cultural expressions
of fantasy," Snyder says, "was the change in the images from
Europe to the U.S., and then from the east coast cities to the bleached
geography of the Southwest. In European stories, the fantastic had faces
resembling ours; their houses and tools, their horses, their arts were
not so different from those of humans. In cities like New York, the fairies
came whole cloth along with the immigrants, moving into tenements and
parks, beautiful homes and back alleys. But in the Southwest, where human
beings stand dwarfed by the hugeness of the sky, by the vast distances,
the fantastic thinned, becoming vaporous like Dust Devils and mirages.
The fantastic took its form entirely out of nature. To live on the southwest
frontier was to live close to both the beauty and the dangerous chaos
of nature, and of the fantastic.
"Yet once I probbed beneath the differences
in the surface images I discovered that the 'function' of the magical
images in the different narratives was the same: to provoke the transformation
of a boy into a man and a hero. To this all cultures speak; and whether
the fairie ride magic horses [as they do in Irish myths] or have a heart
of thorns hidden within a tree trunk [as they do in Mexican-American myths],
they give the hero the same challenges. I relished the differences, the
richness of expression whether one found it in European village life or
in the huge spaces of the American High Plains."
The basic themes of myth and legend do not
change in cultures around the globe, but each land has its distinctive
voice, including Turtle Island. The voice of this land is a chorus made
up of many disparate voices. It is a song that is always changing as new
peoples come and make their home here; as generations live and die here;
and as their ways become a part of the American folk culture. Underlying
all these voices are the older stories of this land -- the tales of the
first Americans, the numerous nations of indigenous peoples . . . .
Part II
The legends of Native America are rich,
complex, and diverse, varying among the many tribal peoples who make their
home across the huge land mass of North America: the Crow, the Cree, the
Blackfoot, the Sioux, the Oneida, the Ojibway, the Hopi, the Shoshone,
the Cheyenne, and hundreds of others. Yet common themes can be found throughout
the stories of many different tribes. Native American legends are often
about the land itself; about sacred mountains, salmon-filled rivers, the
Great Plains, and the myth-haunted deserts of the West. Animals are prevalent
in the tales; they often have human characteristics, intermarry with human
beings, or provide the hero with a special power, blessing, or "medicine."
Father Sky, Mother Earth, and the Grandfather spirits of the four cardinal
directions are an important part of the old myths, as well as of pan-tribal
religions. Certain basic characters appear over and over again: the Hero,
the Trickster, Grandmother Spider and her grandsons, the Twin Gods of
War. While magic is usually invested in the landscape itself or in animal
figures like Coyote, one can also find stories similar to the magical
fairy tales of Europe, such as Cherokee legends of little people who live
under the hills.
For those interested in reading the myths
themselves, there are many good collections to chose from these days --
far too many to name but a handful of favorites here. The Pantheon Fairy
Tale & Folklore Library's American
Indian Myths and Legends, edited by Richard Erdoes and Alfonso
Ortiz, is one of the best introductions to this material that I know of;
I also recommend the new Erdoes & Ortiz collection, American
Indian Trickster Tales. Mourning Dove's Coyote
Stories is a lively, classic source of Trickster myths; The
Nez Perce Coyote Tales have been collected by Deward E. Walker Jr.
and Daniel N. Matthews; and Lewis Hyde's excellent study Trickster
Makes This World is highly recommended. The
Mythology of Native North America by David Leeming and Jake Page
provides a good overview of this material; while The
Dictionary of Native American Mythology (edited by Sam D. Gill
and Irene F. Sullivan) and The
Encyclopedia of Native American Shamanism (edited by William S.
Lyon) are two good reference sources. William Brandon's The
Magic World is a collection of magical songs, chants and poems
culled from many different tribes. Life
With the Little People edited by Robert Johnson Perry collects
the little-known magical tales of the Muskogeans.
Malcolm Margolin's The
Way We Lived is a terrific collection of stories, songs and reminiscences
from tribal peoples of the Pacific coast, as is Grandmother,
Grandfather, and Old Wolf edited by Clifford E. Trafzer. Anne
Cameron's Daughters
of Copper Woman, from the Vancouver Islands in Canada, is a fascinating
source for women's legends. I also recommend Giving
Birth to Thunder, Sleeping With His Daughter, by naturalist writer
Barry Lopez. In addition, you can find hundreds of collections specific
to individual tribes through your local library or under the Native American
heading on the Amazon.com Web site.
When we look at Native American myths, it
is important to remember that these tales are not the remnants of cultures
long buried in the past. They come from living cultures, and a Traditional
way of life still lived by many people in America today, particularly
in the western states. Although some of the stories were created as simple
entertainments, the majority of them are teaching stories and religious
myths -- comparable, in their own context, to the stories of the Judeo-Christian
Bible. It is a startling, little-known fact that until recently there
were federal and state laws that forbid the practice of Native American
religions. The widespread government policy of taking children away from
their own families and shipping them to distant white-run boarding schools,
where they were not allowed to speak their own languages, has caused many
tales and ceremonies to be lost over the years. Fortunately, these repressive
laws have been challenged and are slowly changing. A cultural renaissance
is in progress as young Native Americans reclaim their own rich heritage
(quite similar to the renaissance in Celtic myth, language and music that
happened in Ireland in the 1970s, challenging the English domination of
the culture and sparking the folklore/music/Irish language revival that
flourishes today). Elderly tribal Traditionalists who have been the caretakers
of ancient tales and practices are finding many young people eager now
to keep this oral tradition alive.
The dry text of a printed page cannot convey
the power of a mythic story told in its proper context. We can only imagine
the response of the ancient Greeks or Romans to the legends told in their
day; but it is still possible to hear a Lakota legend such as that of
White Buffalo Calf Woman just as people may have heard the same tale many
generations ago: in the darkness of a sweat lodge, seated cross-legged
on the dirt of Mother Earth, hunched beneath the lodge's circular frame
of bent willow boughs. In the center of the lodge is a round pit, where
the rocks (the Stone People) are brought when they've been heated by a
fire. Water is poured on them, and steam fills the small, dark lodge with
heat. There are prayers, songs, the sound of drums, the spicey scents
of cedar and sage. In between one round of prayers and the next, the door
is opened, the chanupa (pipe) brought in. And the tale is told
of the mysterious woman who brought the first medicine pipe to mankind:
It was a hard winter. Game was scarce,
and the People were slowly starving. Two warriors walked out onto the
plains, and saw a beautiful woman there, wearing a robe of white buffalo
skin embroidered with beads. Seeing this woman walking alone, one man
had a bad thought about her. "We can have our way with her,"
he said to the other, "and no one will know." The other warrior
disagreed. "We will treat this woman with respect." But the
first warrior approached the woman, and put out his hand to touch her.
As he did so, dust swirled up around him, and when it was gone, nothing
remained of the warrior but his bones, picked clean. The woman looked
at the other man and said, "Do not be afraid. You have good thoughts
and a good heart. You will be a messenger for your People. Tell them I
will come in four days, and bring them a gift from Creator."
In four days, the People gathered together
in the largest tipi. The woman in white appeared among them, carrying
a bundle. It was a chanupa made of pipestone and wood, with twelve
eagle feathers hanging from the stem. She gave it to the People, and she
explained, "The smoke of this pipe will carry your prayers directly
to Creator. When you hold this pipe, you must speak nothing but the truth,
for it is very powerful." She taught them seven sacred ceremonies
they would practice with the chanupa, of which the inipi,
the sweat lodge, is one. And then she took her leave of the People, saying
"Toksha ake wacinyanktin ktelo" -- I will see you again.
They all gathered to watch her go, and they
saw as she lay down on the ground, rolled, and then stood up again in
the shape of a black buffalo calf. She walked a little way and lay down,
and this time she was a yellow buffalo calf. She walked a little way and
lay down, and this time she was a red buffalo calf. She walked a little
way and lay down, and this time she was a white buffalo calf. In this
form she trotted over the plains and disappeared.
"Her pipe is still with the Lakota
people today," the storyteller will conclude, "up in Green Grass,
North Dakota. It is very old, very wakan, and only brought out
in times of great need. But every time we smoke a pipe, the prayers of
the first pipe and all the pipes that have ever been smoked mix with our
prayers and are carried up to Creator." Then he will pass the pipe
around, and everyone in the circle will partake, adding their own prayers
and becoming part of an ancient story . . . .
Across this country, such stories are being
told and retold, passed from mouth to mouth: at Sundances, in Vision Quests,
in the dusk-to-dawn Tipi Meetings of the Native American Church, in Bean
Dances and Deer Dances, at intertribal powwows. It is because these stories
are part of a living culture, rather than historical curiosities from
a vanished age, that there is controversy attached to their use as raw
material by fiction writers -- particularly if those writers are white,
using myths that are not their own. This is a controversy that concerns
those of us working in the field of mythic fiction, for ours is a literature
that routinely draws upon the mythic lore of many cultures. Writers of
magical fiction rarely feel constrained to stick to the myths of their
own ethnic makeup. (And using myths from one's own culture can also be
a dicey proposition if those myths touch upon religious beliefs -- as
Salman Rushdie discovered when he wrote The
Satanic Verses.)
Sherman Alexie, a talented young writer
from the Spokane/Coeur d'Alene nation, is outspoken in his condemnation
of non-Indian writers who assume they can understand and depict the Indian
experience. He takes particular exception to the works of Barbara Kingsolver,
who has written about Indian characters although she is only part-Cherokee
and was not raised as an enrolled tribal member. Alexie attacks her frequently
in print and on his book reading tours; his recent novel Indian
Killer is a long diatribe on the subject, thinly disguised as
fiction, in which all the white characters are wicked or foolish and all
the Native characters are noble and misunderstood. Alexie's Angry Young
Indian shtick (a lucrative publicity pose which has made him the
darling of Guilty White Liberals) is a bit absurd (as even my Native friends
point out) coming from someone who writes about white, black, female and
disabled characters while being none of these things himself -- and yet
he is right to remind fiction writers to be particularly careful when
working with the myths and cultures of others. Critics like Alexie are
naturally wary of works by non-Indians that serve to perpetuate destructive
stereotypes -- the literary equivalent of all those awful pastel paintings
of Indians one sees on sale throughout the West, painted by whites and
sold to whites, in which Indian men and women are merely symbols and not
human beings. Yet on the other end of the spectrum of controversy is Tony
Hillerman, a white man who has written a popular series of detective novels
with Native protagonists, set on the Navajo reservation in New Mexico/Arizona.
Far from decrying his use of their culture in his bestselling fiction,
Hillerman has been lauded by the Navajo for his sensitive portrayal of
their way of life, and presented with the Navajo Tribe's Special Friend
Award.
I happen to be a fan of Kingsolver and Hillerman
both, and while I can agree with Alexie that the best work often comes
from a writer's own direct experiences, I personally believe it's ridiculous
to expect all novelists to be limited to this. We are fiction writers,
not reporters. And yet the danger of clumsily working with someone else's
sacred beliefs was demonstrated a couple of years ago when the Hopi tribe
in northern Arizona was appalled to discover the revered kachina figures
of their religion clumsily depicted as the villains of a Marvel comic
book. It proved to be the last straw in a series of incidents disrespectful
of their ways, and as a result, they closed many of their beautiful dances
and ceremonies to non-Natives. It was startling to visit the Hopi mesas
before and after the comic's publication. The casual friendliness extended
to outside visitors seemed to vanish overnight.
The recent revival of interest (among Indians
and non-Indians alike) in traditional Indian ways and beliefs has had
the beneficial effect of making fiction, art and music by Native American
artists more widely available. Because a good portion of these arts are
steeped in the enduring folklore of their cultures, much of it will be
of interest to readers of fantasy and mythic fiction. There is also, despite
the above controversy, good work to be found by non-Indian artists as
well -- such as Tony Hillerman's wonderful "Jim Chee and Joe Leaphorn"
mystery novels, which touch upon Navajo legendry and beautifully evoke
the mysticism of the vast Southwestern landscape.
Both Indian and non-Indian writers have
contributed to Tales
from the Great Turtle, a collection of "Fantasy in the Native
American Tradition" edited by Richard Gilliam and Piers Anthony.
I'd suggest skipping the embarrassing Anthony introduction and heading
directly for the stories. Tales by William Sanders, Jack Dann, Steve Rasnic
Tem and Kristine Kathryn Rusch are particularly notable, and while some
of the stories are slight, the collection as a whole is a worthy endeavor.
Also in the fantasy genre, take a look at Orson Scott Card's Red
Prophet; Eric S. Nylund's Dry
Water; and Charles de Lint's excellent "Coyote Stories"
(in his collection The
Ivory and the Horn), as well as de Lint's novels Svaha,
Spiritwalk,
Memory
and Dream and Someplace
to Be Flying.
It is on the "mainstream" shelves,
however, that you will find some of the best of the current fiction inspired
by Native American legends. Three of my favorite mythic novels of all
time fall into this category: La
Maravilla, by Yaqui writer Alfredo Vea Jr., set in the Arizona
desert; The
Antelope Wife by Chippewa writer Louise Erdrich, set in modern
Minneapolis; and Power
by Chickasaw novelist/essayist/poet Linda Hogan, set in the swamps of
Florida. All three are brilliant and I can't recommend them too highly.
Thomas King's hilarious Green
Grass, Running Water is a wild, mythic romp set among the Indians
of modern Canada. King's Medicine
River is also a terrific novel, and his short stories, collected
in One
Good Story, That One, seem to have been written by Trickster himself.
Leslie Marmon Silko, like the authors above,
writes about Indian characters caught between traditional and modern worlds.
Ceremony
is about a World War II prisoner of war returning to his Pueblo reservation;
the more recent Almanac
of the Dead is an extraordinary work sprawling across Arizona
and Mexico, ignoring all such Anglo-drawn borders. N. Scott Momaday is
a writer and visual artist who, like Silko, has a home in Tucson, Arizona
and writes about the Southwest. His brilliant novel House
Made of Dawn won the Pulitzer Prize for fiction; his magical novel
The
Ancient Child is also recommended. Susan Power's The
Grass Dancer, set on a reservation in the Dakotas, is a gorgeous
multi-generational saga, magical, romantic, and highly recommended. Susanna
Moore's Sleeping
Beauties is another all-time favorite, using native Hawaiian folklore
to tell a compelling contemporary tale. Luci Tapahonso writes movingly
about her Navajo family in northern Arizona in her exquisite little book
of poems and stories, The
Women are Singing. We Are O'odham and other poetry volumes
by Tohono O'odham writer Ofelia Zepeda of Tucson is also recommended.
Pawnee writer Anna Lee Walters has created
a splendid book of art and text called The
Spirit of Native America: Beauty and Mysticism in American Indian Art;
it is one of the best books on the subject I've seen, modestly priced
and handsomely presented. Turning from historic Indian art to modern art,
I recommend Fritz Scholder: 30 Years of Sculpture, recently published
by Nazraeli Press. Although best known as a painter (and for his association
with Georgia O'Keeffe and the Santa Fe school of art), this Native artist's
first collection of sculpture is a revelation, and should not be missed.
English painter/illustrator Susan Seddon Boulet was raised in South America
and heavily influenced by Native imagery from both South and North America.
Her art is collected in Shaman,
published by Pomegranate Press. Mark Wagner is a painter who has worked
with Native American imagery and ritual for many years. "I believe
that art is sacred and inseparable from life," he says about his
paintings, which are "focused on the direct connection between nature,
spirit, and the human race." You can see his work on the Hearts
and Bones Studio Web site, and on our Gallery
suite.
Steve Wall has recently compiled interviews
and photographs of Indian women across the country into a terrific book
called Wisdom's
Daughters: Conversations with Women Elders of Native America.
Charles L. Woodward has published a book of conversations with writer/artist
N. Scott Momaday, Ancestral
Voice, an interesting look at Momaday's background and creative
process. Gary Snyder works with Native American and naturalist themes
in his poetry (such as the collection Turtle
Island) and in his nonfiction work The
Practice of the Wild -- a brilliant and inspiring book. In Coyote
Medicine, Dr. Lewis Mehl-Madrona (of the Lakota and Cherokee tribes)
looks at the differences between Native and Anglo healing practices, as
well as the role of storytelling in the healing process. For an introduction
to Native American spiritual beliefs, try Evan Pritchard's lovely little
book No
Word for Time, Ed McGaa's Mother
Earth Spirituality, and (for women) Marilou Awiakta's Selu:
Seeking the Corn Mother's Wisdom.
No exploration of art rooted in Native American
lore would be complete without a mention of the music being recorded today
by talented musicians such as R. Carlos Nakai, a Navajo/Ute master of
the Native American Flute. These flutes, according to a Brule Sioux legend,
were made for one kind of music: love music. A warrior might be too shy
to speak to a woman he desired in front of the entire village. So at night
he would put all of his desire into the low, moaning cry of the flute,
and if the "medicine" was strong in him, the woman would hear
his words in the sound, slip from her tipi and meet him in the dark . . . .
R. Carlos Nakai has recorded several CDs
combining traditional flute tunes with haunting music of his own. The
result is utterly magical. I particularly recommend
Ancestral Voices (with William Eaton), and How
the West Was Lost (the soundtrack from the PBS documentary). Nakai
also plays in the band Jackalope, which adds rock and jazz rhythms to
this material. Walk
In Beauty by the inspired team of Primeaux & Mike features
the exquisite music of The Native American Church -- reminiscent (in the
slower, harmonic form developed by Primeaux & Mike) of Gregorian chanting.
Between
Father Sky and Mother Earth is a compilation CD from Narada, which
features Primeaux & Mike, Nakai and many others -- a good introduction
to the music. Bill Miller, of the Stockbridge-Munsee tribe, is a singer/songwriter
who combines traditional and original tunes; his The
Red Road is a powerful, wonderful CD (with a nice bit of back-up
from Peter Rowan and Tish Hinojosa). Sharon Burch has created original
songs from the traditional music of her Navajo ancestry on her beautiful
CD Touch
the Sweet Earth. Rita Coolidge, Priscilla Coolidge and Laura Satterfield
have teamed up on Walela,
featuring gorgeous women's music inspired by the Cherokee tradition. Burning
Sky's Blood
of the Land features entrancing instrumental music with a jazz
influence. Things
We Do by Indigenous is good blues-rock from a Minnesota Nakota
family band. Robbie Robertson (of The Band) and the Red Road Ensemble
have recorded Music
for the Native Americans, which is actually music for anyone who
likes rhythms to be found at the intersection of traditional music and
rock-and-roll.
At a recent concert, R. Carlos Nakai (decked
out in traditional braids and beaded shirt, along with blue jeans and
running shoes) complained about the term Native American. "We're
all Native Americans," he says; "all of us who were born on
this land; all of us who attempt to share it with greater and lesser efforts
at harmony."
When Europeans first came to these shores,
they demanded native peoples adapt to their ways (when they weren't wiping
them out altogether). Now many of us are doing what those early settlers
should have done back then: listening to the people who know this land
best, learning its ways, its own history. Blood and culture have intermingled
over the generations since those first settlers came. It is the task of
the next generations to find strength in this, instead of divisiveness.
One step in that process is to listen to legends and stories of the first
Americans, for these myths are the heart and voice of the land that is
now home to us all.
|
About the Author:
Terri Windling is a writer, artist, and editor, and the founder of the Endicott Studio. For more information, please visit her Endicott bio page.
Copyright © 1997 by Terri Windling. This article appeared in Realms of Fantasy magazine, 1997, and may not be reproduced in any form without the author's express written |
|
Copyright © 1997-2004 by The Endicott Studio |
|